JPost: Health Minister German outlaws fluoridation of all tap water

Here is another in our series of posts regarding mandatory medical treatment.

An article by Judy Siegel-Itzkovich reports that the Israeli Health Minister, Yael German, has directed that Israel's water cupply should no longer be fluoridated.

But she added that instead of forcing all Israelis to consume fluoridated water to benefit children’s teeth, the delivery system should be changed so each parent can decide and take action individually if they wanted their child to get dental protection...

Prof. Arnon Afek, German’s director-general whom she recently handpicked and who is an expert in pathology and medical administration (but not dentistry or public health), told The Jerusalem Post Sunday that he personally supported the health minister’s decision to prohibit fluoridation. “Mandatory fluoridation is medical treatment. Individuals have the right to decide if they want it or not. The question is not if fluoride is beneficial but how it should be delivered. We cannot force people. It is legitimate that experts in the field oppose the health minister’s decision, but we have a policy,” said the director-general. “The ministry supported it for over 40 years, but this is a new era. The world has changed, and we can educate parents.”

Israel Hayom | Court orders teen to undergo chemo against rabbi's advice

In the past, I have written about the courts mandating medical treatment, see here and here.

Israel Hayom is reporting a case where the court is ordering a boy to go undergo chemotherapy and radiation treatment for his leukemia. According to the article, the boy was treated in the past and his cancer was in remission. His doctors are saying it has returned by the boy and his family are refusing treatment, according to the article, on the advice of their rabbi. 

"If they could prove that this treatment is necessary, we would agree to it," said the boy's father.

It is not clear from the article whether the rabbi has seen the medical report.

See here for an article entitled How A Rabbi Decides A Medical Halacha Issue by Rabbi Yitzchok A. Breitowitz.

US Doctors to be Waived in to Israel- JPost

According to a JPost article, US doctors who have passed the USMLE need not take the Israeli medical licensing exam but will be waived in.

The exemption from the local licensing exam will be retroactive, granting a license to whoever has passed the USMLE in the past decade.

This is the first time that Israeli health authorities have accepted foreign test results for an MD license.

But someone who has taken an Israeli licensing exam and failed may not ask to take the USMLE exam and receive an exemption; he will be able, however, to resit the local exam instead.

I don't expect to see a similar rule for lawyers anytime soon. First of all, Israel seems to need more doctors so this will help ease the shortage while there is a glut of lawyers in the country. Second, the human body is the same in every country and medicine is fairly standardized whereas the legal system in the US and Israel, while similar, has many differences. On the other hand, lawyers who have passed the bar exam in one of the 50 states and has 5 years of experience need not pass the Israeli bar even if they can barely read Hebrew or know anything about the Israeli legal system. One can always hope...

Man Attacks Estranged Wife in Hospital- New Law Should Prevent Re-occurrence

Apparently, violence in health care facilities is a problem in Israel worthy of its own law.

The JPost reported today that a man attacked his estranged wife and hospital staff in the maternity ward. In May they reported on 3 brothers of a woman who was placed in a emergency shelter for domestic violence victims who went to the social worker’s home with clubs and iron bars and beat up her husband and other family members. According to a report at the Health Policy Monitor:

A comprehensive study conducted in 2003/4 on violence in emergency rooms in Israel (Landau et al. 2004) revealed that 75% of the medical staff reported a violent incident in the past year. Most reports related to verbal violence, but 29% reported threats and 16% physical violence...

This problem receives growing media attention; it was debated in the parliamentary committee for work welfare and health in 2007. During 2008, several academic conferences were dedicated to the issue and discussed measures to address it.